Sometimes, the most haunting cases aren’t the ones splashed across headlines — they’re the ones buried in dusty folders, tucked away in a locked drawer that no one talks about anymore.
In the basement archives of the Oldfield Police Department sits one such drawer, labeled simply: “Case File #472 — Restricted.” For decades, only a handful of detectives have been allowed to see what’s inside. Today, we’re taking a peek into the shadows.
The Case That Never Made the News
In 1989, Detective Alan Evans was working burglary detail when he stumbled upon a bizarre break-in at an abandoned farmhouse on Riverbend Road. The farmhouse had been empty for nearly 15 years, but the intruder left behind more than footprints.
Inside the living room, Evans found:
-
A manila envelope containing photographs of different women — all taken without their knowledge.
-
A map of Oldfield with red X’s scattered across specific residential streets.
-
A handwritten list of names — none of whom had any obvious connection to one another.
The strangest part? Every name on the list belonged to someone who, within the next year, vanished without explanation.
Why It Went Quiet
Evans quickly realized he was on to something big — but when he brought the file to his superior, the investigation abruptly stopped. The official explanation was “lack of evidence,” but colleagues whispered about interference from higher up.
The file was removed from active investigation, sealed, and locked in Evans’s desk. He refused to speak about it, even after retirement. When asked about #472 in a rare interview, he simply said:
“Some doors should never be opened… unless you’re ready for what’s behind them.”
A Chilling Twist After Retirement
In 2016, Evans passed away. While cleaning out his personal effects, his family found a small brass key with “472” scratched into it. They turned it over to the police, but the department has refused to confirm whether the drawer was ever opened again.
Theories from the Shadows
-
Serial Stalker: The photos, maps, and disappearances suggest a calculated predator operating for years.
-
Inside Job: Some believe the culprit was connected to law enforcement, explaining why the case was buried.
-
Mistaken Connections: A few argue that the links between the names and vanishings might have been coincidence — though that’s a hard sell to most.
This Secret Files Sunday, we want your take:
If you had the key to Case File #472, would you open it — or leave the mystery locked away forever?
Add comment
Comments